Astrology and Astronomy Compared
Astrology and astronomy grew from the same roots for a very long time. Today astronomy is the science that explains the universe through observation and testing, while astrology is a symbolic system that gives meaning to positions in the sky.
| Origin | Babylon, around the 5th century BCE, where the 12 signs were organized |
|---|---|
| In antiquity | Ptolemy wrote both an astronomy book (Almagest) and an astrology book (Tetrabiblos) |
| Split | After the Scientific Revolution of the 17th century |
| Best-known test | Carlson's 1985 double-blind experiment in Nature found chance-level personality matching |
They began from the same roots
Ancient Babylonians and Greeks recorded planetary motion with great care, used it to make calendars and predict seasons, and at the same time believed changes in the sky were tied to events on Earth. Around the 5th century BCE the ecliptic was divided into twelve signs, and in the 2nd century CE Ptolemy wrote both an astronomy book and an astrology book. At the time they were one subject.
When did they split?
In the Scientific Revolution of the 17th century, from Copernicus and Galileo through Kepler and Newton, astronomy moved toward explaining the sky with telescopes and mathematics. Kepler cast horoscopes to earn a living but criticized astrology for not matching observation. Once gravity explained planetary motion, nothing was needed to say that star positions shape personality.
How they differ
- Astronomy: observes and calculates, and revises theories that fail. Anyone repeating it gets the same result.
- Astrology: interprets positions of celestial bodies as symbols. Interpretations differ by astrologer and school.
- In common: the mathematics for computing positions is the same. Planetica calculates positions with astronomical formulas and borrows astrological tradition for interpretation, to be read for fun.
Has astrology been tested?
Several studies have tested astrology. The best known is Shawn Carlson's 1985 double-blind experiment in Nature, which reported that astrologers matched birth charts to personality profiles no better than chance. On evidence like this, the scientific community regards astrology as having no demonstrated predictive power.
Many people still enjoy sign talk as a way to reflect or start a conversation. For big decisions about health, money or relationships, rely on your own judgment and qualified professionals, not a horoscope.
On Planetica
The horoscope and birth chart tools compute the real positions of the Sun, Moon and planets astronomically, then give a reading for fun. To see how signs differ from the real sky, read Zodiac Signs vs Constellations.
Read more
- 9 Types of Planets
- Star Types and Colors: Spectral Classes O, B, A, F, G, K, M
- What Is a Nebula? Emission, Reflection, Dark Nebulae and Supernova Remnants
- What Is the Habitable Zone (Goldilocks Zone)?
- The Sun
- The Moon
- Solar and Lunar Eclipses
- What Causes the Seasons
- The Life of a Star
- The Milky Way and Galaxies
- Black Holes
- Exoplanets
- Zodiac Signs vs Constellations
- Sun, Moon and Rising Signs
- Zodiac Elements and Modalities
- Weight and Gravity on Other Planets
- Planet Years and Your Age
- Astrology and Astronomy Compared
- Meteor shower calendar and how to watch
- What Mercury retrograde really means
- Why isn't Pluto a planet?
- How to find the North Star
- How far is a light-year?
Last updated:
Create your own planetary system
Enter a name and a birthday to get a one-of-a-kind planetary system, placed next to a real star in your birthday constellation.